Green Hydrogen production

n5o4 edited  29.04.2023 copyright by

If services or offers from third parties or standards are obtained, no guarantee can be given for the correctness of the information at the present time.

We're referring to the production of green hydrogen up front because everything else (grey hydrogen and blue hydrogen) doesn't really make sense.

The aim is to make the use of hydrogen available as a transportable energy carrier. This means that hydrogen can replace diesel and heating oil.

The picture shows a complete line from production to consumer.

 


Production H

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Energy supply

Hydrogen production primarily starts with electrolysis (even if there are other processes, but they don’t give much in terms of quantity or the efficiency is still too low.)

Since then, the efficiency of electrolysis has generally been reported to be around 70%. Advances at Wolongong University in Sydney, Australia, who developed a capillary process, have increased this efficiency to almost 100%. In the technical implementation, 95% are specified. This progress means a quantum leap for hydrogen production.

In the first step, electrolysis produces gaseous hydrogen H2 and (not to forget) medically usable oxygen O2 in a gaseous aggregate state.

There are now two options for further processing: either the compression of gaseous H2 in pressure tanks or the liquefaction to H liquid and storage at low pressure and low temperature (cryogenic tanks).

The comparison of the methods shows the following:

Both methods require a certain amount of additional energy.

Compression: In gaseous H2 compression, this is the compression work required to store a reasonable amount of energy in a tank. We are talking about pressures > 300 bar.

Liquification: When the gaseous H2 is liquefied to form liquid H2, around 30% of the energy that is stored later is required as additional physical work = energy.

If we put the additional energy required in each case in relation to each other, we quickly understand that the advantage lies in liquefaction: there is a pressure limit for the compression of gaseous H2 above which the process is no longer worthwhile compared to liquefaction.

The energy required for production can either come from wind farms or large photovoltaic systems. Of course, other energy sources from the field of non-fossil renewable energies are also possible. Or the surplus production of other power plants that cannot be used on the market at certain times of the day.


Usage

 

fuel cells

In order to make the use of hydrogen as an energy source successful, it is not only necessary to think about the production, but also about the use.

Here again two options come into question: Combustion in piston engines or turbines with an electrical efficiency of 27% or the use of fuel cells with an electrical efficiency of 60% (mean value).

It is clear that preference should be given to fuel cell technology. 


Industrial needs

 

 

 

 

 

Invests on
clients site

In order to make the use of hydrogen as an energy source successful, it is not only necessary to think about the production, but also about the use.

Here again two options come into question: Combustion in piston engines or turbines with an electrical efficiency of 27% or the use of fuel cells with an electrical efficiency of 60% (mean value).

It is clear that preference should be given to fuel cell technology.

Given the high energy requirements of industry, it makes sense to think about X x 1,000 kWh when procuring and storing energy.

And with liquid hydrogen, this can also be done without difficulty:

1 m3 H liquid has an energy content of 3,000 kWh = 3 MWh at a mass of 75 kg.

  • Using a fuel cell stack (f = 2/3) this results in around 2,000 kWh = 2 MWh of usable electrical energy out of 1 m3 H liquid.

  • Using combustion (f = 1/3) this results at 1,000 kWh = 1 MWh of usable mechanical energy out of 1 m3 H liquid.

In the picture we assumed a delivery quantity of 5 m3 in exchangeable tanks. This is a manageable quantity for delivery with a small truck and corresponds to a usable amount of energy of 10,000 kWh = 10 MWh using fuel cells for providing electricity.

For this result, it is worthwhile for the consumer to provide the technical systems for maintaining the cryogenic low temperature and the fuel cell stack.

 


H-Production in Details

In the following, the primary calculations for the subject of hydrogen are presented in a practically usable approximation.


A reasonable truck load of H

As the preliminary considerations show, it makes sense for various reasons to switch the supply of large consumers such as industry and municipal energy supply facilities to liquid hydrogen: much more energy fits into the same volume!

The calculation below shows the results for a truckload with a tank volume of 5 cubic meters, which is a common tank size.

Of course, this solution is not for private households, since the customer has to provide the corresponding cryogenic cooling technology for -253 °C.


Markets and market chances of H

The following figure shows an overview of the various power supply lines:

 


 

Market launch

 

Arguments

 

 

 

Stationary use

European market

 

Mobile use

Energy storage

Electricity supply fails

African market

South America

Asia

Basic framework

One thing is clear: the launch of any new product in a market depends on two factors: the quality of the product and the price.

A market launch will not succeed with environmental protection alone as an argument.

Discussion

1. As long as green = free primary energy is used for production, the cost-related disadvantages of more complicated handling of Hydrogen and the investment required by consumers (fuel cells, etc.) can be compensated, so that it is questionable what will ultimately cost more. Furhter investigations are necessary.

2. Finally, for an fair comparison, the costs of the entire process chain must be calculated (because that is what the possible final price is based on) and conventional power plants and their maintenance are by no means cheap either. In addition, conventional power plants need fuel, which has to be procured and transported, and that also creates costs, and it does in the long run.

3. For (a) stationary use (b) in the European market, the direct supply of electricity from solar and wind power (or hydropower as has been the case since) is certainly the cheapest alternative. It will also be the most favorable in terms of investment costs for equipment. So the European entrepreneur calculates his costs against the price of electricity.

4. For (c) mobile use (worldwide) and for (d) use in markets with constant power failures, the ability to refuel / store energy is a decisive criterion. This is exactly where liquid hydrogen with its high energy density comes into play: rule of thumb 15 MWh in 5 m^3 volume at 380 kg weight.

Mobile heavy equipment are ships, airplanes, construction machines, trucks and locomotives. Due to their size, all of them are suitable for accommodating the corresponding transport containers and the necessary technology.

And with 15 MWh in the tank, you can go a long way. For regions with an unreliable power supply, there is anyway a need to stockpile energy; Companies there do not calculate their costs against the price of electricity, but against the loss of production.